← All posts

November 15, 2026 · 2 min read

31% of retailers saw AI make a wrong account action. Who approves your refunds?

New Talkdesk research found that 31% of retailers using AI saw it take an incorrect action on a customer's account, such as an improper refund. With the holiday rush starting, here is how a small business can keep a person on the money decisions.

When your busiest season arrives, who will decide whether a customer gets a refund, a person on your team or an AI agent?

This question matters more than usual right now, because the holiday rush is when returns and exchanges pile up.

What the research found

Talkdesk, a company that sells AI customer service software, released its 2026 AI Holiday Shopping Survey on November 4, 2026. It surveyed 312 U.S. retail decision-makers at companies with 50 or more employees that use AI, plus 1,048 U.S. holiday shoppers, in September 2026. This is vendor research, so I read it with that in mind.

Here is what stood out to me. 93% of these retailers plan to use AI agents in customer service this holiday season, and 51% of those planning AI service agents want them to handle returns, refunds, or exchanges. Yet 31% of retailers using AI said their tool took an incorrect action on a customer's account in the past 12 months, such as an improper refund.

Separate Salesforce research, published November 12, 2026, found that most shoppers will abandon an AI assistant after two or three mistakes.

Why it matters for a small business

A refund is not just a task. It is money, and it is a moment of trust with a customer who is already a little unhappy. If an AI agent gets it wrong during your busiest weeks, you may not notice until the customer is gone.

This is where Human-in-the-Loop AI helps. Let the agent gather the order details, check your policy, and prepare the answer. Let a person approve anything that moves money. Automate the process, not the relationship.

What I would do this week

  • List every action your AI agent can take on a customer's account, and mark the ones that involve money.
  • Set those actions to "prepare and wait for approval" instead of "do it automatically."
  • Pick one person to review pending refunds at least twice a day through the holidays, so customers are not kept waiting.

My takeaway: Your customers may forgive a slow answer, but they will remember a wrong one. Let AI do the legwork and keep a caring human on the decisions that touch their money.

Sources

  1. Retailers are betting on AI agents for holiday shopping, but consumers refuse to hand over their wallets · Talkdesk via GlobeNewswire, on FinancialContent (vendor research, November 4, 2026)
  2. New Data: Holiday Shoppers Will Rely on Agents. Retailers Must Be Ready. · Salesforce (vendor research, November 12, 2026)